En anglais seulement.
Print this page
That is terrible to hear.
This certainly is an interesting video. I am an electrochemist, and the science here seems solid, but I did a few back of the envelope calculations and in the short term this is not an efficient means to reduce our GHG emissions. Let me explain: This technology removes about 0.25 g CO2 / Wh of energy expended. A coal power plant produces about 1 g CO2 / Wh. So it would be 4x more efficient to build the solar towers that this guy is promoting and use them to produce electricity for the grid (instead of CO2 removal), thereby replacing a coal (or natural gas) plant.
However, this technology could certainly be helpful for removing CO2 from the atmosphere AFTER we eliminate fossil fuel burning power generation.
In case you’re curious, my calculations suggested that to reduce Canada’s emissions by 30% below 2014 levels would require 8 GW of generating capacity from solar concentrator towers, which would cost about $44 Billion USD based on the cost of the recent Ivanpah solar tower project and would take up an area half the size of Toronto. If you want to be realistic about the fact that the solar towers only operate during daylight hours, you’d have to double or triple the number of towers required (i.e. $90 – $120 Billion).
All the best, and thanks for bringing this technology to my attention!
Thanks for the reply. I didn’t even know where to start with regard to calculating the cost and feasibility of it, so i appreciate your calculations.
Just the fact that we COULD do it, that it’s even possible to pull the carbon out is good news in my book. How bad does it have to get before 44 billion sounds like a bargain? I hope not too much worse, because the longer we let the earth warm the less likely it is that we could stop the domino (or cascade) effect even if we pull the co2 out (if the Arctic melts, then no amount of carbon removal will help).
I hope that after these climate talks the world realizes that we need proactive action (freezing the Arctic and carbon removal) to have any real chance of the species surviving on earth.
Second reply – ontario is nuclear, we could use that to run this machine. It doesn’t help with the costs, but it does offer a carbon negative option.
Second question, could you build these into large buildings that are being made more energy efficient – thereby making the building carbon negative and sharing the electrical costs across many businesses /people? Offset install costs with a tax credit (because it’s more important to get the carbon out of the air then it is to not go into debt).
(E) Statement on Lyme Disease Awareness Day 2017 May 10th, 2017
(E) Mental Health Week 2017: Reforms needed to mental health services to improve well-being and boost the economy May 3rd, 2017
(E) Elizabeth May pleased with C-51 committee report, but urges government to go further May 2nd, 2017
(E) Statement on Canada-U.S. softwood lumber dispute and exporting of raw logs May 1st, 2017
(E) Statement on National Day of Mourning April 28th, 2017
(E) Update on Electoral Reform December 1st, 2016
(E) COP21 Final Blog – Day 13 December 13th, 2015
(E) COP21 Day 12 December 12th, 2015
(E) COP21 Day 10 December 10th, 2015
(E) COP21 Day 8 – Negotiations move behind closed doors December 8th, 2015
(E) Why was a national autism strategy not in this year’s budget? May 18th, 2017
(E) Statement on the International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia and Biphobia May 17th, 2017
(E) Parliament: Will the government reconsider pipelines approved through the deeply flawed NEB process? May 17th, 2017
(E) Auditor General slams Liberals for failing to provide numbers in phase-out of fossil fuel subsidies May 16th, 2017
(E) Parliament: Questioning the use of time allocation to limit debate on Bill C-7 May 16th, 2017
Bureau de circonscription 1-9711 rue Fourth Sidney (C.-B.) V8L 2Y8 Tél: 250-657-2000 800-667-9188 Télec: 250-657-2004 Courriel: firstname.lastname@example.org
Bureau d'Ottawa 518 Confederation Chambre des communes Ottawa (ON) K1A 0A6 Tél: 613-996-1119 Télec: 613-996-0850 Courriel: email@example.com
Emplois et Bénévolat Cliquez ici pour les dernières opportunités