We are into serious over-time…

On Friday, November 22nd, 2013 in Blogs

I am writing this from the Warsaw airport in the wee hours of almost Saturday morning.  I left the ADP interactive process after 3 AM when the co-chairs adjourned, sending the weary negotiators away for a few hours rest, while the co-chairs and their team prepare a new text. This will be the 5th version.  Negotiators, some remaining cool as a cucumber, others emotional and angry as the COP seems destined to under-deliver against the low expectations that awaited it two weeks ago, have been increasingly fractious. The usual diplomatic niceties have occasionally fallen away.

Even one of the most polished and old school diplomats, representing a developing country, made a searing comment as the talks went on  — and on. He pointed out that the “context of this COP must be acknowledged and that context is backsliding by developed countries; reneging of commitments that were legally undertaken. There has been a total abdication of leadership by developed countries.  The irony of discussing a new treaty, with legally binding commitments, in the context of countries violating previous legally binding commitments raises questions to the credibility of this process.”

Yes, it does.  Other delegates from the global south became even more impassioned, expressing out loud their distrust of the industrialized country governments.

One of the more amazing things about the multilateral system is the discipline of diplomats.  The super-human effort required, particularly for countries with small teams of negotiators to keep going – on little or no sleep, for days on end. And to continue to talk even when those who understand the science and know their country is at risk of more loss of life, of losing years of progress in development, have to continue to make nice across the table with those nations that could do something about it, but don’t.

This COP had the added disadvantage that there was no food available in the stadium after about 9 at night.  (No problem for me since I fasted while in Warsaw in solidarity with Yeb Sano of the Philippines.) One delegate complained that it must violate the UN Charter of Human rights to work people in this fashion.

Friday started for me with a closed meeting of the G77 and China.  I have been attending all week. The incredible opportunity to attend these meetings as a member of the Afghanistan delegation was something I had not imagined when I I volunteered to help. If I had turned my mind to it at all, I would have expected to be kept out of those rooms.  I thought my role was only to prepare policy advice, assist with the High Level speech, and to stay on top of sessions where no one from the Afghanistan government had the ability to attend.  That I would be given the rare chance for a Canadian to witness the internal consultations of this huge and fascinating negotiating group was an extraordinary opportunity.

The cohesion of the group is astonishing as it contains the poorest of the poor (the LDC, Least Developed Countries Group), the African Bloc, AOSIS (the Alliance of low lying Island States), as well as China, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Brazil and India – over 130 nations in all.  Their different circumstances and perspectives lead to different positions on many issues, but the functioning of the group under the gavel of the Chair, this year from Fiji, the courtesy and respect, was impressive.   The closing session Friday morning ended with an emotional statement of appreciation for the support and solidarity of the group from the Philippine delegation, met with prolonged applause.

From there, the rest of the day is a blur.  Most of the time I was in the ADP interactive, but when the chairs adjourned for a few hours to allow for some rest, I went to track what was going on in Finance and Loss and Damage – two different interactive groups both led by co-chairs (the UN tradition is to have each contact group or side negotiation be led by co-chairs, one from the industrialized world and one from a developing country.)

In none of the groups was the work anywhere near finished.  New texts were announced, first as the chairs explained what they had hoped to capture in common ground – always admitting it was far short of what was required and of what delegations wanted, but asking , almost begging, for a spirit of good will and compromise.

After the short review of a text no one had yet seen, it was made available hard copy at the side of the room (only in English).  All delegates would stampede to grab the text and start the process of detailed review of old text versus new, tallying up whether ground was lost or gained, in order to prepare positions once the sessions resumed.

The over-riding sense of the day was “we cannot leave Warsaw with nothing to show for two weeks of negotiating. We must have, at least, a work plan to go forward to 2014, its additional meetings and COP 20 in Lima.”

The ADP group broke down at around 11 pm when there was an emotional outburst from Venezuela condemning the European Union for trying to control the process.  That led to the co-chairs deciding on a break for people to try to sort out some compromise.

It is almost impossible to believe, but the next phase was a 2 and a half hour “huddle.”  Thirty or so country representatives literally had to stand in a corner of the room, pressed up against each other, (some complained that it got hot and fairly malodorous as they had to stay rather close to hear what was being said) to negotiate a compromise.  One woman delegate from a developing country complained the process excluded her country because she was too short to hear what was going on in the middle.  Canada’s Ambassador on Climate Dan McDougall was one of those in the huddle and while I deplore his negotiating instructions, I sympathize with the physical toll that this whole process takes on everyone.  (although clearly, wealthy countries with big delegations, Canada’s was over 50 people, are in a much better position to work in shifts and get some breaks).   While the huddle went on in the corner, delegates mostly milled around the room.

By about 2 in the morning the huddle had completed its efforts to come up with new language for paragraph 2(b) and 2 (c.)   The chairs resumed the formal meeting (which also, by the way always took place without benefit of translators so everything was English only).

And that brings me to where I started this blog.  I left at 3:30 in the morning for the airport.  There was no clear indication when I left of whether any text was approved, in any area of negotiation. The likelihood is that a few hours from now COP19 will limp to an ignominious finish line. No one is likely to cheer from the sidelines.

Print this page

  • Ally Robertson

    Thanks Elizabeth for working so hard for us all. ♥

    • Cris Paunescu

      You missed the point: she works “for us all” (actually for her constituents) when she does her job as an MP, not when she works as a note taker for Afghanistan or (whatever she did) for India. By her own words, she missed work in the House – while getting paid. Her “work” in Warsaw has absolutely no significance for this country. In fact, her criticism of Canada and our ELECTED government is actually hurting the country that is paying her.

      Btw, while she admits that world emmissions went up over the last 20 years depite COP, Kyoto, EU cap and trade disaster and such, she failed to mention that Canada’s emmissions went down 5% since 2005.

  • Greg Abbott

    Sounds crazy,,, must be incredibly frustrating, especially for the smaller delegations. Thanks for the insights Elizabeth!

  • Jim Pinkerton Collingwood ON

    Wow…wow, insight Canadian citizens would never know without your MASSIVE effort and unbreakable spirit. You are a true CHAMPION. I admire your commitment to the people and the planet.

  • Joe Lanteigne

    Having your Blog every day is the perfect example of what a representative of the people should be doing. Transparent inclusive democracy. Lifting the veil of secrecy. This comes naturally for you but you do it intentionally and for a purpose. You give Canadians hope and leadership and make us proud.

    • Cris Paunescu

      Actually, her job as a “representative of the people” is here in this country, not in Warsaw. She only represents the Green Party there.

      “Lifting the veil of secrecy”? I’m sorry, what are you talking about?

      • angela

        Wow cris. This is boring without mentils!! I hope they weigh in. Your bullying in the last forum and mentils response sure didnt teach you anything.

        • Cris Paunescu

          Indeed, as he presented only valid arguments, right?

          Please explain the “bullying” accusation.

          • angela

            Are you see serious Cris – you don’t see how what you do is bullying?? Hahaha!!!! Also, I think Mentils arguments were no more ridiculous than yours!

            Also – I believe Joe was referring to you as a troll Cris, but maybe both of you. Not sure. BUT bring it back! So entertaining!

        • Joe Lanteigne

          Angela what did I tell you about feeding the trolls

  • drkcdd

    Reading these blogs has brought the “reality” of the process to light… otherwise these very important meetings would seem a world away and a vision conjured in my mind… nothing like the truth of the situation. Thank you for making it real for us to stimulate new thought and discussion Elizabeth !!

How you can help

Follow Me

facebook-icon Facebook Twitter YouTube Digg


Learn how to support Elizabeth May with her work in Parliament ALT

Island Tides

8,000 year old ancient relic sand under Petronas pilings
October 18th, 2016

Stop Kinder Morgan
October 3rd, 2016

Pipeline Politics, the NEB, Energy East and why so few notice our lack of refineries
September 17th, 2016

Hot climate news in Canada
September 3rd, 2016

1968 and my experience of the Chicago Convention
July 25th, 2016

Latest Blogs

COP21 Final Blog – Day 13
December 13th, 2015

COP21 Day 12
December 12th, 2015

COP21 Day 10
December 10th, 2015

COP21 Day 8 – Negotiations move behind closed doors
December 8th, 2015

COP21 moves to new phase
December 7th, 2015

Green Party Logo

Constituency Office

1-9711 Fourth St
Sidney, BC  V8L 2Y8

Phone: 250-657-2000
Fax: 250-657-2004

E-mail: elizabeth.may.c1a@parl.gc.ca

Parliament Hill Office

518 Confederation Building
House of Commons
Ottawa, ON  K1A 0A6

Phone: 613-996-1119
Fax: 613-996-0850

E-mail: elizabeth.may@parl.gc.ca